pxl

Tits out for the motherland!

Are French sex workers wittier? The prostitute as a marker of national sexual character.

 | Published in 

Circulating Subjects: Sex Work and Migration in Russia, 1885-1935

Philippa Hetherington

(Cornell University Press, 2026)

Selling French Sex: Prostitution, Trafficking, and Global Migrations

Elisa Camiscioli

(Cambridge University Press, 2024)

Desiring Whiteness: A Racial History of Prostitution in France and Colonial Senegal

Caroline Séquin

(Cornell University Press, 2024)

Other countries and nationalities have always featured in people’s sexual fantasies — and moral judgment about those fantasies. Linguistically, France has loomed large. From the late nineteenth century onward in much of Europe and the Americas, condoms were « French letters », porn was called « French pictures », and blowjobs were doing it « French » style. For the overindulgent, there was the « French pox »: syphilis. 

For their part, the French called syphilis the « Spanish disease » and condoms « capote Anglaise », invoking the image of a penis in a raincoat. In Europe and the Americas, « Greek » was slang for anal sex. In Germany, « American Bars » were known for the waitresses who offered sex alongside cocktails, and after the Russian Revolution, Bolsheviks blamed prostitution on Americans. In turn, Americans often spoke of the titillating evils of the « European bordello », articulating a sense of a cohesive yet dangerous European sexual character. 

If nationalism is « inseparable from the desire for power », as George Orwell noted, then it makes sense that it is often envisioned in gendered and sexual terms. During World War I, propaganda posters personified alliances and enemies through curvy allegorical women. The Triple Entente — Marianne, Mother Russia and Britannia — are tall and voluptuous, with their tresses cascading past bare shoulders. As men shoot and stab each other in the background and comically phallic Zeppelins demonstrate dominance in the air, these three knockouts with accentuated décolletage give them something to fight for.

In the nationalism beauty contest, however, Marianne is the clear winner. Eugène Delacroix’s massive 1831 painting La Liberté guidant le peuple still hangs in pride of place in the Louvre. In it, Marianne — bare breasted, bayonet in one hand and a tricolor in the other — bounds over a heap of fallen men. While some critics said she looked like a whore, others saw her bare breasts as a symbol of her purity, a connection to the nude marbles of antiquity. 

People are still talking about her. In the summer of 2013, France’s prime minister, Manuel Valls, pointed to Marianne’s naked breasts as evidence of her maternal nature, and as proof that it should be illegal for women to wear burkinis on French beaches. « She is not wearing a veil because she is free! Right there, that is the Republic! » Tits out for the motherland!

(Complicating Valls’s interpretation is evidence that Delacroix’s Marianne was based on a strikingly similar illustration, published in 1725, of a female pirate, breasts bare to symbolize her lawlessness, sexuality and violence.)

If the idea of the nation is often embodied by a woman, then the prostitute is also a marker of national sexual character — the dangerous whore lurking behind the Madonna. For those interested in the history of sexuality, focusing on prostitution is also a more practical matter. Commercial sex is one of the few places where what is ostensibly private becomes public, the subject of state law and policy, a place where sex leaves archival traces.1 It is also how sex becomes enmeshed in the market, where fetishizations of other nations who do it « Greek » or « French » can be translated into cash.

While nationalist sexual tropes in themselves are ridiculous, their histories provide an interesting opportunity to see where nationalism as an « imagined community » rubs up against deeply embodied desires and experiences. Three recent books approach these tropes from different angles. 

In Selling French Sex: Prostitution, Trafficking, and Global Migrations, the US historian Elisa Camiscioli introduces us to the figure of the sexy French woman from a somewhat surprising source: French officials in the 1920s falling all over themselves to proclaim the « skill » of the French prostitute, which « no other prostitute can equal ». Most sexual stereotypes are imposed by one nation onto another, but here, the French state was proud to claim its sex workers as « more responsive, gayer, more witty, and playful » than those of any other country. 

The book explores how a whole host of characters — ranging from police and immigration officials from various countries, international coalitions of social reformers, as well as pimps and sex workers themselves — imbued « Frenchness » with global erotic cachet in the twentieth century. Her telling connects the intimate bodily encounters of French sex workers with the international political debates over commercial sex. « French sex » did not organically arise from the bodies of French women, Camiscioli demonstrates, even if that was the official line. Instead, its meaning was « made in Havana, Buenos Aires, Chicago, Geneva, and other cities, as much as it was in Paris. » 

Camiscioli locates the germ of French sex in the early nineteenth century, with the creation of state-licensed brothels in Paris. There, officials registered women as prostitutes and regularly inspected their vaginas for signs of syphilis and gonorrhea. Police had broad discretion about who they could register as a prostitute: at times they just registered women walking alone on the streets.2 Once on the registry, it was difficult for a woman to remove her name. 

But it was all for an important cause, French officials believed. Undergirding the system was a deeply held assumption that men had potent sexual energy and had to regularly (though not excessively!) ejaculate for their health. This idea was based on ancient Greek ideas, generally shared by European physicians and the public until well into the nineteenth century. The brothels, and the women within them, acted as a « seminal drain », according to one doctor, keeping men healthy and protecting « respectable » women from rape or overuse.

This system quickly spread throughout Europe and its colonies, and then to Central and South America, where it often retained an identity as a « French » system, even as it was tweaked to suit local circumstances. Yet it did bear the mark of French republican discourse, which insisted on individual rights and liberties, including the ability to have sex, sell sex, and express one’s sexual desire — in many ways equating sex with freedom (for men at least). 

We might think of anxieties over trafficking as a contemporary phenomenon. These anxieties today include both well-founded concerns about exploited labor, as well as fear-mongering attempts to expand state powers of policing and border control.3 

But the anti-trafficking movement has a deeper history, one which Camiscioli shows often served similar nationalistic aims. By the late nineteenth century, governments in Europe and the Americas grew increasingly concerned that foreign men were kidnapping young girls and trafficking them to brothels abroad. At the same time, they worried, undesirable foreign pimps and prostitutes were flooding burgeoning cities. Governments convened multiple conferences on this « white slave trade ». (While women of color could be labeled as « white slaves », these campaigns focused almost entirely on white women.) The conferences ended in signed international agreements that called for the repatriation of women found in foreign brothels, based on the idea that no woman would consent to migrate and sell sex. 

The French strongly disagreed with this characterization. As one French official put it, « prostitutes have a perfect right to travel and to circulate freely ». French women did migrate in large numbers, particularly after the devastation of World War I, and many sold sex. Camiscioli places this migration within the context of labor migration to the Americas in the 1920s, as millions of people crossed the Atlantic in search of better work and better pay. 

But an international network of anti-trafficking experts didn’t see it this way. To them any migratory prostitution, indeed, even a woman selling sex in her home country, was a sign of trafficking. In the 1920s, investigators working for the League of Nations traveled throughout Europe, the Americas and North Africa to understand the scope of this problem. To do this, they visited a lot of brothels. 

Some of Camiscioli’s richest material comes from the notes that investigators produced as they skulked about red light districts. In the Cuban capital of Havana, a French woman who gave her name as « Ginette la Parisienne » reported that she made five times more in the high-end brothel on Calle Virtudes than she did in Paris, and her family back home needed the money. It was also far more money than she could have earned during grueling twelve-hour days, six or seven days a week, as a domestic servant, textile factory worker or seamstress — occupations in which some bosses also demanded that female employees sleep with them. 

Indeed, French women selling sex in the fancier houses in Cuba could earn a life-changing amount of cash. Even women who weren’t actually French claimed that they were, though notably this option was only available to white women. Both brothel owners and sex workers exploited the association of Frenchness with titillating fashions, sumptuous Parisian brothels, and the « mysterious pleasures » of oral and anal sex, practices forbidden within « respectable » marriages. French women were also known for taking clients of all races, another taboo for white women. 

There was a practical side to all of this, as Camiscioli explains. Women selling oral sex could work while they were menstruating and could service more clients in less time to make more money. And women who would sleep with Black and Asian men had a much larger client base. As both a personal and economic calculation, Ginette’s choice — made within the colossal constraints of poverty, limited employment options and family obligations — made a lot of sense.

Camiscioli also reads these notes to turn an eye back on the investigators themselves, showing how their own desires shaped their accounts. Indeed, their observations at times read more like a letter to Penthouse than a bureaucratic report. After entering the brothel on Calle Virtudes, investigator George Worthington spotted Ginette across the room. She was « probably the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in any house of prostitution anywhere » with « pearl teeth » and a « very fair complexion ». He danced with her, noting how her breasts were exposed by her low-cut silk beaded gown when she moved. With this kind of leering gaze, investigators wrote reports that made « French sex » into a social scientific fact. 

In 1917, a French Indochinese soldier stationed in Marseille wrote home about breaking a well-known prohibition. As he put it, « here, there is nothing surprising, except for French women’s vaginas. It costs three francs to fuck. » In Desiring Whiteness: A Racial History of Prostitution in France and Colonial Senegal, 1848-1950, Caroline Séquin — a historian of modern France and its Empire — starts from a seeming paradox in French history. European empires generally forbade relationships between white women and men of color — sexual and otherwise — to maintain racial hierarchies that placed white colonizers firmly on top. But French republicanism’s universalism posed a problem. As one French administrator lamented: « our laws do not tolerate differentiations based on color or race. » 

In fact, France cared just as much as other empires about dictating « who bedded and wedded with whom », to use historical anthropologist Ann Stoler’s phrase. During World War I, nearly half a million men from French colonies in Africa, Asia and the Caribbean were brought to the French metropole to fight. French administrators and the general public feared these « troupes indigènes » were especially sexually voracious. Sex between white French women and such men would represent « colonization the wrong way round ». As Séquin shows, these anxieties were visible on the cover of a popular French magazine, which depicted a white woman dining with a Senegalese soldier. Titled L’Enfant du dessert, it made clear what was coming after this dinner party: sex and a mixed-race child.

In earlier conflicts, the French military had experimented with transporting West African women to staff brothels for Senegalese troops. But the sheer number of colonial troops in the French metropole during World War I made such a solution impractical. Instead, Séquin details, French military officials decided to prevent these men from having sex with white French women outside the brothel by encouraging them to visit white French women within the brothel. Indeed, French army officials organized outings to local brothels for colonial troops and even helped them to negotiate down the price of sex.

It was in this context that a colonial Indochinese man could brag about sex with a white French woman. Of course, we only know about his exploits because Séquin discovered his letter in a folder of materials seized by censors to prevent them from reaching home, where they could give colonial men ideas. In this way, French brothels operated as « gatekeepers of whiteness », a carefully controlled container for interracial sex that would (or so French officials fervently hoped) keep its effects from spilling over and challenging French colonial rule and the deeply held idea of France as a white nation.

Camiscioli documents how for many contemporary observers both within and beyond France, the brothel was a hallmark of French sexual decadence: « elaborately equipped for every conceivable form of perverse indulgence ». Séquin shows how brothels worked as a tool of white supremacy, in a country whose stated ideals left it with a limited toolbox. 

In her new book, historian Philippa Hetherington demonstrates how looking at Russia can give us a new perspective on France — and indeed, the idea of a shared European sexual culture. At the fin de siècle, Russia’s uneasy place in « liberal » Europe was also articulated in sexual terms. Circulating Subjects: Sex Work and Migration in Russia, 1885-1935 (Cornell University Press, 2026) traces how Russian debates over prostitution and trafficking positioned Russia within international politics. The book was published posthumously, after Hetherington died of cancer at age 38. 

Less interested in individual experiences like the ones Camiscioli teased out of the archives, Hetherington’s focus on political ideology instead shows the global political stakes of debates over prostitution. 

She is particularly attentive to the continuities between Russia and France. Some are obvious: like most other countries in Europe, in the mid-nineteenth century the Tsarist government adopted the French model of regulated prostitution to keep a tight grip on social order. At other times, the continuities are less obvious. After the Russian Revolution, the government rejected regulated prostitution as a relic of the Tsarist past and advanced a Marxist reading of prostitution. But while they talked a big game about workers « seizing the means of production », they didn’t actually mean women seizing the sexual and reproductive power of their own bodies. 

As a prominent socialist feminist proclaimed, the Soviet state would be « a flag bearer » of a new approach to prostitution, one that did not control women’s bodies through French-style regulation. Instead, the state would remove « any need for women to engage in commercial sex in order to support themselves or their families, » — attacking the social and economic roots of the problem. 

This sounds great in theory. In practice, it was more complicated. Soon, Soviet officials stressed that prostitution did not exist in the Soviet Union at all. Yet as Hetherington shows, given the political and economic chaos of post-revolution, post-World War I Russia, prostitution very much did exist and was becoming increasingly common. Officials deemed prostitution « criminal work avoidance » and prostitutes « socially harmful elements », and sent them to labor colonies for training in « productive » work. 

Battles over the connection between prostitution and the political economy played out across Europe and the United States. As Lenin sneered, under capitalism « the free, cultured America supplies living goods to brothels! » On the other side, the US ambassador to Russia erroneously reported that under communism, some provinces had « gone so far as to nationalize their women ». 

But despite the Soviet Union’s and Europe’s supposedly opposite approaches to prostitution, Hetherington understands French regulation and Soviet prohibition as two sides of the same coin. Both gave the state control over women’s bodies, their mobility and their labor — even as one government encouraged commercial sex and the other criminalized it.

While its stance on prostitution positioned Russia as outside of liberal Europe, Hetherington finds that the international anti-trafficking movement helped to frame Russian women as Europeans. In the 1930s, a League of Nations investigation into sex trafficking in Asia found a small number of Russian women working in brothels and as dancers in China (a relatively small number in comparison to thousands of Asian women selling sex both within and beyond their native countries, but unexpected, nonetheless). Despite little evidence of forced migration or forced sex, the investigation deemed them innocent « European sex slaves », even as the Soviet Union’s status as part of Europe was far from evident. White women selling sex in a country deemed not white became idealized victims — Europe’s own rather than an Eastern other. 

White Russian women’s sexuality became celebrated as their defining feature — a trope still with us today. The 1990s Russian « mail-order bride » has a clear place in this genealogy. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, American media were soon filled with sensational accounts of awkward, unappealing American men picking young, sexually alluring Russian women out of catalogs. In reality, such cases accounted for far less than one percent of female immigration, while just as many, if not more, Asian women also entered for such marriages. And the trope can be found in the emails released in January 2026 as part of the Epstein files. One photo of two women sent for Epstein’s approval came with the note, « They are both Russians. ; ))) » 

In 1997’s Titanic, Kate Winslet’s Rose asks Leonardo DiCaprio’s Jack to « draw her like one of his French girls » before she undresses and drapes herself over a couch wearing only a necklace. The line remains ridiculous and embarrassing, to the point that it has become a meme. But as one of millions of teenagers who saw the film in theaters and repeatedly rented a two-tape VHS at my local Video Station, I understood exactly what she meant. Being a « French girl » was to be a sexual person — a sexual subject rather than a sexy object, although I would not have used those words at the time — in a world that did not shame girls for their desires and bodies. It was far from the world in which I lived, one where Winslet was dragged in the press for being fat and having gross boobs she made us look at. 

Nationalist tropes are « useful fictions », to borrow James Joyce’s phrasing. But stories are up for grabs — one country or person doesn’t get to control them. That’s why Frenchness could expand an American teen’s sexual imagination in the 1990s even as it was fashioned through state control of French women’s bodies over a century earlier.

To French physicians, French prostitutes were « seminal drains ». To the United States military, their « vagina becomes a veritable petri dish », spreading disease and immorality. To French colonial troops, they were a means of subverting colonial hierarchies. As one North African solider declared in a letter home, in France « a kilogram of vaginas costs five sous ».

For women who sold sex, their vaginas were not metaphors. They were a part of their bodies from which they made a living, often a far more profitable living than was available in any other occupation. Nationalistic stereotypes did have real exchange value for some (white) women who sold sex. By using them, as well as helping to shape them, these women savvily navigated the limitations of their material circumstances. 

Although most accounts we have of women who sold sex at the turn of the century are mediated through the pens of antagonistic investigators, police or the courts, some wrote the stories of their own lives. Camiscioli is careful to excavate these accounts and present them alongside the official versions. One of the most powerful is the autobiography of Frenchwoman Marthe Watts, born in 1913, aptly titled The Men in My Life. It chronicles her travels across France, Spain, Italy, Great Britain and French colonial North Africa in the twentieth century.

« How did I become a prostitute? » asked Watts, a question that clients often asked her. Hers was « no story of juvenile delinquency » or of « deep-seated psychological » problems. Rather, her father was killed at Verdun; her mother remarried and abandoned her. She had no parents, no home, no dowry. As she wrote, « It is perhaps these circumstances, as much as any proficiency we might pretend to in the art of love, that have occasioned French girls to cater for the promiscuous desires of men. » Watts did not make sense of her life either as solely a story of concrete material constraints or one of fantastical French sex, a story of unsurmountable oppression or unbridled agency. Instead, her experience lay somewhere in the space between the two.

  1. Historically and today, queer men and trans people have also been involved in commercial sex, though cis-women were the majority of sex workers. I focus here on cis-gendered women because they were the focus of nationalist campaigns. ↩︎
  2. As a London newspaper reported, police « were hunting » a seemingly innocent woman on Paris’ Boulevard Haussmann one afternoon to put her on the prostitution rolls. « She refused to submit, and climbed up one of the trees. » ↩︎
  3. I am thinking particularly of the 2023 film Sound of Freedom, a based-on-true-events conservative American wet-dream, in which former US government agent Tim Ballard rescues sex-trafficked children in South America. The real Tim Ballard was later accused of mismanaging donor funds and sexually assaulting female co-workers. ↩︎

Read MORE

“` The only changes from before: the `wp:separator` is gone from the right column, and both columns now have `border-bottom` declared identically in their block attributes — same mechanism, same pixel row.